Chippin Jerky vs Chippin Treats: Which Dog Snack to Pick?
By Eco-Friendly & Sustainably MadeProducts | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Comparisons
Compare Chippin Wild-Caught Fish Jerky and Superfood Cricket & Pumpkin Dog Treats on protein, texture, and allergens to choose the right snack for training or daily rewards.
Quick answer
Choose Chippin Wild-Caught Fish Jerky for soft, chewy training bites that are allergen-free and rich in omega-3s. Choose Superfood Cricket & Pumpkin Dog Treats for oven-baked daily rewards that add natural fiber for gut health. Both are sustainable, so your pick depends on texture, protein source, and whether you need a training tool or a daily snack.
Protein source and what it means for your dog
The jerky uses sustainable silver carp, an overpopulated wild fish, while the treats use cricket protein. If your dog has been sensitive to common proteins like chicken or beef, both offer novel options—but fish is often a safer bet for dogs with poultry allergies. Cricket protein is still less familiar to many owners, so introduce it slowly if your dog has a sensitive stomach.
Texture and training convenience
Fish jerky is soft and chewy, which makes it easy to tear into small pieces for quick rewards during training. The cricket treats are oven-baked and firmer, so they work better as a daily snack or a longer-lasting chew. If you need high-frequency rewards, jerky’s texture gives you an edge.
Allergen and digestive considerations
The fish jerky is explicitly allergen-free, which is helpful if your dog reacts to common fillers. The cricket treats include oats and peanut butter—both potential allergens for some dogs—so check the full ingredient list if your dog has known sensitivities. The added pumpkin and oats in the cricket treats provide natural fiber, which can support digestive regularity.
Key trade-offs to weigh
- Protein novelty vs. familiarity: Fish is a more familiar protein for most dogs, while cricket is novel and may require a slower introduction. If your dog has a sensitive stomach, start with small amounts of either. Introduce cricket protein gradually over a week to watch for reactions.
- Training vs. daily reward: Jerky’s soft texture makes it easy to break into tiny pieces for frequent training rewards. The cricket treats are firmer and better suited for a daily snack or a calm chew. Keep a bag of jerky in your training pouch and cricket treats in the pantry for regular rewards.
- Allergen profile: The fish jerky is allergen-free, while the cricket treats contain oats and peanut butter. If your dog has known allergies, review the ingredient list before choosing. For dogs with multiple allergies, the fish jerky is the simpler choice.
Product facts at a glance
- Superfood Cricket & Pumpkin Dog Treats, 4-Pack: Cricket protein, pumpkin, and oats add natural fiber to support gut health. This makes the treats a good choice for dogs that need a little digestive support in their daily routine.
Superfood Cricket & Pumpkin Dog Treats, 4-Pack - Wild-Caught Fish Jerky, 4-Pack: Soft and chewy jerky made from sustainable silver carp, with omega-3s for skin and coat. The texture is ideal for training, and the omega-3s offer an extra benefit for dogs with dry skin.
Wild-Caught Fish Jerky, 4-Pack
Which treat fits your dog?
Best for
- Dogs in active training that need soft, breakable rewards
- Dogs with poultry or grain sensitivities that need an allergen-free option
- Owners who want to support skin and coat health with omega-3s
Not for
- Dogs that need a firmer, longer-lasting chew
- Owners looking for a daily treat with added fiber for gut health
- Dogs with fish allergies
